/ 10 on our bench
Is Bullymake worth it for a power chewer in Australia?
Yes, on the month-to-month plan.
The Commitment Ledger: 7 of 14 plans reach Australia
$50 a box, $34 prepaid for twelve.
No commitment, no fee, in Bullymake's words.
- 4 to 5 toys a month, no treats: the only box Australia can receive
- Cancel anytime by email or live chat, no fee
$228 total prepaid, plus $8.00/month shipping to Australia: $276 all in, $46 a box delivered. Both of those are our arithmetic on the vendor's numbers. A real 6-month commitment.
- 4 to 5 toys a month, no treats, 6 boxes
- Eligible to cancel once your 6th shipment is complete; renews automatically after unless you switch auto-renewal off
$408 total prepaid, plus $8.00/month shipping to Australia: $504 all in, $42 a box delivered. Both of those are our arithmetic on the vendor's numbers. The longest commitment on the grid.
- 4 to 5 toys a month, no treats, 12 boxes
- Eligible to cancel once your 12th shipment is complete; renews automatically after unless you switch auto-renewal off
Multi-month plans are a commitment: in Bullymake's own words "early cancellation fees may apply" before it ends, the plan auto-renews once it does, and cancelling only happens by email to customercare@bullymake.com or live chat.
Where the link lands, and Bullymake's own words on the commitment
Bullymake has no separate purchase link per plan: our tracked link points at Bullymake's own site.
From there, Bullymake's own Join Now / Subscribe Now buttons open the same plan picker audited below, where you pick your box, commitment and payment method yourself.
Read the table once before you click. Bullymake's own words: "When you select a multi-month plan, you are committing to the length of the plan you selected. If you wish to cancel your subscription before the end of your initial plan commitment, early cancellation fees may apply."
Each subscription "automatically renews once the initial plan commitment is completed" unless you turn off auto-renewal yourself, and canceling is only possible by email to customercare@bullymake.com or live chat, never a self-serve button.
The seven Toys & Treats rows are printed because they are on the vendor's page, not because you can buy them: an order placed from Australia is switched to the Toys Only row of the same length, at the Toys Only price. Read the bottom half of this table as yours.
| Box | Commitment | Billed | Price/box | Total (our arithmetic) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Toys & Treats | 1 month | Month-to-month | $45 | n/a, no commitment |
| Toys & Treats | 3 months | Monthly pay | $37 | billed monthly |
| Toys & Treats | 3 months | Prepaid | $37 | $111 |
| Toys & Treats | 6 months | Monthly pay | $33 | billed monthly |
| Toys & Treats | 6 months | Prepaid | $33 | $198 |
| Toys & Treats | 12 months | Monthly pay | $29 | billed monthly |
| Toys & Treats | 12 months | Prepaid | $29 | $348 |
| Toys Only | 1 month | Month-to-month | $50 | n/a, no commitment |
| Toys Only | 3 months | Monthly pay | $42 | billed monthly |
| Toys Only | 3 months | Prepaid | $42 | $126 |
| Toys Only | 6 months | Monthly pay | $38 | billed monthly |
| Toys Only | 6 months | Prepaid | $38 | $228 |
| Toys Only | 12 months | Monthly pay | $34 | billed monthly |
| Toys Only | 12 months | Prepaid | $34 | $408 |
Where the prepaid totals come from
All six prepaid totals in this column ($111, $126, $198, $228, $348, $408) are our own arithmetic: box count × the per-box price Bullymake prints on its own subscribe page, confirmed on our live re-check September 1, 2026.
Add $8.00/month shipping to any multi-month plan shipping to Australia, against $4 inside the USA, per Bullymake's own FAQ. On the Toys Only rows that means $46 a box delivered on the 6-month prepaid plan and $42 a box delivered on the 12-month prepaid plan (box price plus the $8.00 monthly shipping). And per the same FAQ, "Canada and Australia cannot receive shipments with treats," so a Toys & Treats order from Australia is automatically switched to Toys Only.
What this means for you
What this means for you: the month-to-month plan is the one with no lock-in at all, cancellable any time with no fee in Bullymake's own words, so you can see a box before you decide anything.
Every dollar figure above is the standing price, and the per-box price falls as the commitment gets longer.
The long verdict, and who it suits
The company answer is the same in Australia as it is anywhere: yes, if what you want is a subscription backed by a company you can actually verify. Bullymake is owned by Compana Pet Brands, a real, named operator with a BBB profile rated A+, and Bullymake's own Trustpilot page carries a 4.4 out of 5 TrustScore across 2,289 reviews, both fetched directly on September 1, 2026, making it the strongest reputation signal on this bench.
The subscription terms are printed in Bullymake's own FAQ: multi-month plans are a commitment where "early cancellation fees may apply," the subscription renews automatically once that commitment ends unless you switch auto-renewal off, and canceling is done by email or live chat.
The Australia answer is narrower. All 14 plan and payment combinations matched Bullymake's own subscribe page exactly on the day we checked, and 7 of them are the ones an Australia order lands on: every order becomes the Toys Only box at $50, $42, $38 or $34 a box, plus $8.00 a month shipping on a multi-month plan, charged in US dollars. Of the two guarantees Bullymake runs, only one reaches you: the 3-day refund window on an unopened box. The 45-day toy replacement is written, in Bullymake's own words, for "original, end-user purchasers in the United States."
Good fit, if you
- want a subscription company you can verify is real, not a dropshipping shell: Compana Pet Brands, BBB A+ as of Sep 1, 2026, Trustpilot 4.4/5 across 2,289 reviews
- are happy with 4 to 5 toys and no treats, which is what an Australia box contains by the vendor's own rule
- have a strong chewer and want a genuine replacement guarantee when a toy loses, not just a marketing promise
- are comfortable starting month-to-month and only locking into a longer, cheaper-per-box commitment once you've seen a box or two
- are in Australia: Bullymake ships here, and the offer behind this page covers subscriptions from the US, Canada and Australia
What happens after you click, step by step
The five steps, from the click to the first box
- Click any link on this page. It opens Bullymake's own site at bullymake.com through our tracked link; there's no separate deep link per plan, so it lands on the home page, and Bullymake's own Join Now / Subscribe Now buttons from there open the same plan picker audited below.
- Choose your commitment (1, 3, 6 or 12 months), then monthly pay or prepaid on multi-month plans. Whichever box you click, an order to Australia is switched to Toys Only, so the price you end up paying is the Toys Only row of the Commitment Ledger above, plus $8.00/month shipping on multi-month plans, charged in US dollars.
- If you picked anything longer than 1 month, note the date: you're committed for that many shipments, in Bullymake's own words, and the subscription renews automatically afterward unless you turn off auto-renewal yourself, which you can do at any time.
- Then it ships: Bullymake sends the first box out the next business day by DHL, 5 to 10 business days in the continental US and 10 to 15 outside it, so Australia sits in the 10 to 15 bracket, and every box after that arrives on a 30-day cycle. You can ask support to stretch that cycle to every 2 or 3 months instead.
- Keep the receipt date: money back is a 3-day window from receipt on an unopened box. Support, replacement claims, frequency changes and cancellation all run through customercare@bullymake.com or live chat, and you can switch off auto-renewal yourself at any time and still receive the boxes you already paid for.
Order-path details read from Bullymake's own /pages/subscribe flow and FAQ on September 1, 2026.
The Australia file: five things that are different here
You are billed in US dollars, your box is the Toys Only box with 4 to 5 toys a month, shipping is $8.00 a month on a multi-month plan, delivery runs 10 to 15 business days by DHL, and the guarantee written for your order is the 3-day refund window on an unopened box.
The five, each one in Bullymake's own wording
- You are billed in US dollars, not Australian ones. Bullymake's own FAQ answers its own question this way: "What Currency Am I billed in? You will be billed in US Dollars. All prices displayed on our website are in US Dollars." Every dollar figure on this page is therefore a US dollar. Your card issuer converts it at its own rate on the day it bills you, and any foreign transaction fee your card charges is added on top of that; the amount of that fee is set by your bank, not by Bullymake, so check your own cardholder agreement rather than a number on a review page.
- No treats cross the border, so the box changes on its own. Bullymake's FAQ, verbatim: "At this time, Canada and Australia cannot receive shipments with treats. We are working with both borders. Orders will automatically be switched to our 'toys only' option which includes 4-5 toys per shipment!" Pick Toys & Treats from Australia and you are buying Toys Only at the Toys Only price.
- Shipping is $8.00 a month on a multi-month plan. The same FAQ: "A shipping fee of $4 applies to multi-month plans within the USA. Shipping to Canada and Australia costs an additional $8.00/month."
- Delivery runs 10 to 15 business days, by DHL. Bullymake ships the first box the next business day by DHL, and its own FAQ gives 5 to 10 business days inside the continental United States against 10 to 15 outside it. Australia is in the second bracket.
- The 45-day replacement guarantee is written for purchasers in the United States. Bullymake's own guarantee text limits it to "original, end-user purchasers in the United States." The separate 3-day refund window on an unopened box carries no country wording in the refund policy, so that one is yours in Australia.
How to reach Bullymake from Australia
Support, replacement claims, plan changes and cancellation all run through customercare@bullymake.com or the live chat widget on bullymake.com.
The FetchBench scorecard
Five axes, scored one by one. The bench verdict above is set on the full offer as sold, and the axes below show where it comes from.
The five axes, scored one by one
Reputation & trust
9.6/10Compana Pet Brands is a real, named operator with a BBB profile rated A+; Bullymake's own Trustpilot page carries a 4.4/5 TrustScore across 2,289 reviews, both fetched September 1, 2026. The strongest reputation signal on this bench.
Subscription & commitment honesty
9.3/10Bullymake's own FAQ states plainly that multi-month plans are a commitment where early cancellation fees may apply, that the plan auto-renews once that commitment ends, and that canceling only happens by email or live chat. We print all three before the price grid.
Price & plan transparency
9.2/10All 14 plan and payment combinations matched Bullymake's own subscribe grid exactly on September 1, 2026, shipping add-ons included.
Guarantee clarity
8.4/10Two guarantees, each in Bullymake's own words: a 45-day toy replacement (1/month, for purchasers in the United States) and a 3-day refund window on unopened purchases. Every score on this card was set on the full offer as sold in the United States; in Australia the refund window is the one written for your order.
Power-chewer value
8.8/10Real toy variety across nylon, rope, rubber, ballistic fabric and plush materials per box, backed by an actual replacement guarantee rather than an unbacked toughness claim.
What's actually in a Bullymake box
Why the box archive matters, and what is in each box type
Bullymake rotates its box theme every month; its own /pages/our-boxes archive shows dated flat-lay photos going back to January 2023, real evidence of an actual physical product that has shipped for 3-plus years, not a single hero shot recycled forever.
The Toys & Treats box carries 2 to 3 toys plus 3 treats made in the USA; Toys Only carries 4 to 5 toys and no treats at all.
The 5 toy photos below are Bullymake's own real product photography for individual toy types, fetched directly from its own CDN, not AI-generated art or stock photos.
Box and toy photography read directly from bullymake.com's own public CDN (/pages/our-boxes, /pages/toy-types, homepage), fetched September 1, 2026.
The box, as Bullymake photographs it
Product photographs of the box and the toys are Bullymake's own, published on its store and fetched from its own CDN. The backyard pictures of dogs on this page are our illustrations. The treats shown are the United States box; orders from Australia ship the Toys Only box.
The 45-Day Satisfaction Guarantee: a toy replacement for purchasers in the United States
Bullymake's own FAQ, verbatim:
"If one of our toys, purchased from an authorized retailer, meets its match with your dog's jaw of justice, or it's just not the right fit for your pup, let us know within 45 days of your purchase. We'll replace it with a different toy type (limit to one per month), no questions asked."
The clock, the country limit and how to claim it
The more specific clock, also verbatim: claims "must be made within 45 days from the date of receipt of your last box." The restriction, also verbatim: the guarantee is "limited to original, end-user purchasers in the United States."
That sentence sets the country line: the replacement guarantee is written for purchasers in the United States, and the refund window below is the one written for your order. We print the clause in full because it is the piece of Bullymake's offer that does the heaviest lifting.
For a US buyer, claiming it means photographing the destroyed or unwanted toy and emailing it to Bullymake's support; the replacement ships free, capped at one per month.
This is the real shape of Bullymake's "durable" positioning: not a promise nothing breaks, a promise that if it does, you get a different toy to try next.
The Three-Day Window: when it's actually a refund
Bullymake's own refund policy, verbatim, in relevant part:
"We will refund any purchase within 3 days of receipt if you are unhappy with your purchase. Your items may not be used or open to qualify for a refund. If a toy was destroyed or your dog didn't like a specific item in the box, we will replace it for free."
Read plainly: Bullymake refunds a purchase within 3 days of receipt, with the box sealed and unused.
The three days, and what to do in them
The window runs 3 days from receipt; we print it here so it is on your calendar from day one.
What this means for you in Australia: the 3-day refund window is the one written for your order, so decide before you open the box. If the contents are not what you wanted, say so within 3 days of receipt with the box unopened, and Bullymake refunds the purchase.
FetchBench rule of thumb: match the plan to your confidence, not the price break. Month-to-month first, then upgrade to a prepaid commitment once you've actually seen how your dog treats a box.
$50/box in US dollars, Toys Only, month-to-month · no commitment
Who reads this bench
Photos are for illustration.
Every question, answered plainly
Is Bullymake legit?
As a company, yes: Bullymake is owned by Compana Pet Brands, a real, Chesterfield, Missouri operator with a BBB profile rated A+, and Bullymake's own Trustpilot page carries a 4.4 out of 5 TrustScore across 2,289 reviews, fetched directly on September 1, 2026.
Read our Replacement Clause and Commitment Ledger sections for the guarantee and the plan terms in Bullymake's own words.
How much is Bullymake a month in Australia?
Your box is Toys Only, because treats cannot be shipped to Australia, so the row that applies to you is $50 a box month-to-month, $42 on a 3-month plan, $38 on 6 months or $34 on 12 months, read from Bullymake's own /pages/subscribe plan grid on September 1, 2026 and re-read September 9, 2026.
Add $8.00 a month shipping on any multi-month plan. On the 6-month prepaid plan that works out at $276 all in, or $46 a box delivered; on the 12-month prepaid plan, $504 all in, or $42 a box delivered. Those four delivered figures are our own arithmetic on the vendor's two published numbers.
What currency does Bullymake charge in Australia?
US dollars. Bullymake answers this in its own FAQ, verbatim: "What Currency Am I billed in? You will be billed in US Dollars. All prices displayed on our website are in US Dollars." Read September 9, 2026.
So every dollar sign on this page is a US dollar, not an Australian one. Your card issuer converts the charge at its own rate on the day it bills, and if your card carries a foreign transaction fee that fee is added on top. The size of that fee is set by your bank and is in your cardholder agreement.
Why can't I get treats in a Bullymake box in Australia?
Bullymake's own FAQ answers this verbatim: "At this time, Canada and Australia cannot receive shipments with treats. We are working with both borders. Orders will automatically be switched to our 'toys only' option which includes 4-5 toys per shipment!"
In practice, whichever box you pick, your order becomes the Toys Only box: 4 to 5 toys a month at the Toys Only price.
How long does Bullymake take to arrive in Australia?
Bullymake ships the first box the next business day by DHL, and its own FAQ splits delivery into 5 to 10 business days inside the continental United States and 10 to 15 business days outside it. Australia is in the second bracket, so plan on 10 to 15 business days for the first box, then a box every 30 days.
You can ask Bullymake's support to stretch that cycle to every 2 or 3 months instead of every month.
How do I cancel my Bullymake subscription?
By email to customercare@bullymake.com or by live chat, per Bullymake's own FAQ.
A 1-month plan can be canceled anytime with no fee, per Bullymake's own wording. A multi-month plan is a commitment: you're eligible to cancel once you've received all the shipments in that plan (for example, after your 6th box on a 6-month plan), again in Bullymake's own wording.
What is Bullymake's cancellation fee?
Bullymake's own FAQ puts it this way: "When you select a multi-month plan, you are committing to the length of the plan you selected. If you wish to cancel your subscription before the end of your initial plan commitment, early cancellation fees may apply."
A 1-month plan cancels anytime with no fee, and once a multi-month commitment is complete you are eligible to cancel at any time, both in Bullymake's own wording.
Does the 45-day Bullymake guarantee cover Australia?
The 45-Day Satisfaction Guarantee is written, in Bullymake's own wording, for "original, end-user purchasers in the United States." It is a toy REPLACEMENT rather than a refund in any case: one toy per month, claimed within 45 days of receiving your last box.
What reaches you in Australia is the separate refund policy: 3 days from receipt to return an unopened, unused purchase for a refund.
Does Bullymake ship to Australia?
Yes. Australia is one of the three countries behind this offer, alongside the United States and Canada. Shipping to Australia is $8.00 a month on a multi-month plan, per Bullymake's own FAQ, and every order ships as the Toys Only box, 4 to 5 toys a month.
Delivery is by DHL and runs 10 to 15 business days, with the first box shipped the next business day.
What's the difference between the Toys & Treats box and the Toys Only box?
Toys & Treats includes 2 to 3 toys plus 3 treats a month and starts at $45/box month-to-month; Toys Only includes 4 to 5 toys and no treats, starting at $50/box month-to-month, both per Bullymake's own subscribe page.
From Australia the comparison is academic: Toys Only is the only one of the two you can actually receive, since treats cannot cross the border, so $50 a box month-to-month is your real starting price.
Are Bullymake toys really indestructible?
Bullymake builds its toys for power chewers, with real toy variety across nylon, rope, rubber, ballistic fabric and plush in every box, and its own 45-day toy replacement, one toy per month for purchasers in the United States, is the guarantee behind that build.
Is Bullymake worth it for aggressive chewers?
If what you want is a subscription that's upfront about its own commitment math and backed by a real company, Bullymake is a strong pick on this bench: Compana Pet Brands is a verifiable operator, the 14-plan grid checks out exactly against the vendor's own subscribe page, and the replacement guarantee gives a real answer when a toy loses to your dog.
The subscription terms are in Bullymake's own FAQ: a multi-month plan is a commitment for its full length, auto-renewal starts once your commitment ends unless you turn it off, and canceling is by email or live chat.
Start month-to-month if you're not sure yet; save the 12-month prepaid plan for after you've seen a box or two.
Bullymake reviews: what do people actually say?
Trustpilot shows a 4.4 out of 5 TrustScore across 2,289 reviews as of September 1, 2026 (63% five-star, 20% four-star).
A representative positive review, dated August 13, 2026: "My girl is a 6 year old heavy weight champion chewer... She actually still has toys to show off. These are not your typical one and done toys."
Buying tips before you check out
What is worth knowing at the checkout
- Start month-to-month ($50/box Toys Only, the only box that reaches Australia) if you're not sure your dog will stick with it; upgrade to a prepaid plan later once you've actually seen a box.
- A 3, 6 or 12-month plan is a commitment for that length, in Bullymake's own words, and the per-box price falls as the commitment gets longer; cancellation is by email or live chat.
- Turn off auto-renewal yourself once your commitment is set to end, if you don't want a new commitment starting automatically.
- Add the $8.00/month shipping on any multi-month plan to your budget; the charge lands on your card in US dollars, converted by your card issuer at its own rate.
- Optional monthly add-ons in the subscribe-page picker, re-read on Bullymake's own subscribe page September 9, 2026 and unchanged: Extra Toy $9, Calming $9, Dental $9, Hip & Joint $9, all in US dollars.
- Money back is a 3-day window from receipt on an unopened box, per Bullymake's own refund policy.
How we checked this
How we checked this, source by source
This is a research review: on September 1, 2026 we read Bullymake's own /pages/subscribe plan grid, /pages/faq, /pages/our-boxes, /pages/toy-types and /policies/refund-policy word for word, plus the terms of the Everflow offer that credits our link.
- Reputation figures came from Trustpilot's own public profile for bullymake.com, fetched directly on September 1, 2026, not a vendor-supplied number.
- Every product photo of the box and individual toys on this page is Bullymake's own real photography, fetched directly from its own CDN on September 1, 2026; the backyard photography of dogs playing is our own digitally generated illustration, never a Bullymake customer or a stock photo.
- The 14-plan grid above is the standing price, read from Bullymake's own subscribe page.
- The Australia facts on this page (billing currency, the $8.00 monthly shipping fee, the no-treats rule and the automatic switch to Toys Only, the 10 to 15 business day delivery bracket, and the guarantee's limit to "original, end-user purchasers in the United States") were re-read directly on bullymake.com/pages/faq on September 9, 2026, quoted rather than paraphrased, and the per-box grid on /pages/subscribe was unchanged from our September 1 read that day.
- Nothing on this page is veterinary advice.